Thanksgiving: closed at noon Wednesday, November 25 – Sunday, November 29.Christmas: closed at noon Wednesday, December 23 – we reopen Monday, January 4.

Is Your Food Fooling Your Brain? The Science Behind Artificial Flavors and Cravings

Is Your Food Fooling Your Brain? The Science Behind Artificial Flavors and Cravings

Have you ever wondered why a bag of chips, a bowl of cheese-flavored crackers, or a bottle of soda can be so hard to put down? You may think it’s simply the salt or sugar, but there’s a lot more going on. In fact, the food industry has become remarkably good at understanding—and manipulating—what makes food appealing to our brains.

In his eye-opening book The Dorito Effect, author Mark Schatzker explores how modern food production has separated flavor from nutrition. [1] Traditionally, the delicious flavor of food was a natural reflection of the nutrients it contained. Today, however, food manufacturers can create remarkably convincing flavors in a laboratory, making highly processed foods taste like something far more nourishing than they actually are.

For much of human history, our sense of taste and smell helped guide us toward foods that provided energy and nutrients while helping us avoid potentially harmful substances. Sweetness often signaled energy-rich foods, savory flavors could indicate protein-rich foods, and bitterness sometimes warned us to be cautious.

Our brains also learn from experience. Researchers call one important process flavor-nutrient learning. Essentially, when a particular flavor is followed by beneficial nutritional effects in the body, we learn to prefer that flavor. This is a fascinating system designed to help us recognize and seek out foods that nourish us.

But what happens when the flavor and the nutrition no longer match?

Modern food manufacturers can use natural and artificial flavorings to reproduce the taste and aroma of almost anything. A food can taste like fresh strawberries, grilled chicken, or ripe tomatoes without containing much of the actual food that originally provided that flavor.

And here’s something worth knowing: The term “natural flavors” on an ingredient label does not necessarily mean the flavor comes from the whole food pictured on the package, nor does it tell us much about the nutritional value of the finished product.

The concern goes beyond flavor additives themselves. Food scientists have also learned how to combine sugar, refined carbohydrates, salt, and fats in ways that make products exceptionally appealing.

Researchers call many of these combinations hyper-palatable foods. A 2019 study published in the journal Obesity by researchers Tera Fazzino, Kaitlyn Rohde, and Debra Sullivan identified three common combinations associated with hyper-palatability: fat and sodium, fat and sugar, and carbohydrates and sodium. [2] These combinations can create a powerful eating experience that encourages us to keep reaching for more.

And our brains are paying attention! Highly rewarding food experiences activate brain pathways involved in motivation and reward. That doesn’t mean every craving is an addiction, but it does help explain why willpower alone can sometimes feel like a rather unfair contest.

A particularly interesting study conducted by researchers at the National Institutes of Health and published in Cell Metabolism in 2019 put this issue to the test. [3]

Twenty adults participated in a controlled study comparing an ultra-processed diet with a minimally processed diet. Although the meals were matched for several nutritional characteristics, participants consumed approximately 500 more calories per day when eating the ultra-processed foods. They also ate faster and gained weight during that portion of the study.

The researchers couldn’t pinpoint one ingredient responsible for the difference. However, the findings demonstrated that the overall characteristics of highly processed foods can influence how much we eat.

There is another concern worth considering. When our diets become dominated by intensely flavored, highly processed foods, we may gradually become less interested in the wonderful variety of flavors found in naturally grown foods. A fresh tomato, a handful of berries, or a simple roasted vegetable may seem less exciting when compared with foods engineered to deliver an immediate burst of sweetness, saltiness, or savory flavor.

We don’t necessarily need to blame our taste buds. We may simply need to give them a little retraining!

The good news is that our food preferences can change. Here are a few ways to begin:

  • Read ingredient labels. Look for foods made primarily from recognizable, whole-food ingredients. Remember, the ingredient list tells a more revealing story than the front of the package.
  • Eat closer to nature. Choose fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, whole grains, and quality protein sources in forms that haven’t been overly processed.
  • Bring back real flavor. Experiment with fresh herbs, spices, garlic, citrus, and other natural seasonings. There’s an entire world of flavor waiting outside the snack aisle!
  • Give your palate a chance to adjust. As you reduce your reliance on intensely sweet and salty foods, your appreciation for the subtle flavors of whole foods can return.
  • Slow down and enjoy your food. Pay attention to its aroma, texture, and natural flavor. Eating should be an experience, not simply something we do while looking at a screen.

The bottom line? Flavor is not the enemy. In fact, flavor is one of nature’s wonderful ways of helping us enjoy and recognize nourishing foods. The problem begins when flavor is separated from the nutritional value it was meant to accompany.

The body is wonderfully designed to communicate its needs, but we have to give it the opportunity to do so. Perhaps it’s time to stop focusing only on what food can do to excite our taste buds, and really start asking what foods can nourish our bodies in the healthiest way.

The body has an extraordinary capacity to recognize, respond to, and communicate its nutritional needs. But our modern food environment can make that communication more confusing.

We don’t need to outsmart our bodies with another diet or another set of rules. Sometimes we simply need to get back to giving the body what it was designed to work with in the first place: real food, naturally grown, with its flavor and nourishment still together.

[1] Schatzker M. The Dorito Effect: The Surprising New Truth About Food and Flavor. Simon & Schuster; 2015.

[2] Fazzino TL, Rohde K, Sullivan DK. Hyper-palatable foods: development of a quantitative definition and application to the US Food System Database. Obesity. 2019;27(11):1761-1768.

[3] Hall KD, et al. Ultra-processed diets cause excess calorie intake and weight gain: an inpatient randomized controlled trial of ad libitum food intake. Cell Metabolism. 2019;30(1):67-77.